MENU TAMBAHAN
Plagiarims Policy
MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi is committed to upholding the highest standards of academic integrity, originality, and ethical scholarly publishing. To safeguard the originality of submitted manuscripts and prevent plagiarism, the journal conducts similarity screening using appropriate text-matching software, such as Turnitin or iThenticate, depending on the screening service available to the Editorial Board.
1. Similarity Screening Procedure
All submitted manuscripts undergo an initial editorial assessment to determine their relevance to the journal's aims and scope and their compliance with the Author Guidelines.
Manuscripts that meet these preliminary requirements are subsequently subjected to similarity screening before proceeding to peer review.
The screening process identifies textual overlaps between submitted manuscripts and existing scholarly publications, online materials, and other sources available within the software's database.
Similarity reports are reviewed by the Editorial Board to assess whether the identified overlaps reflect appropriate scholarly use of sources or potential concerns regarding plagiarism.
2. Similarity Threshold
The journal applies a maximum overall similarity index of 25% as an initial editorial screening criterion.
Manuscripts exceeding this threshold will normally be returned to the authors for revision and may be resubmitted following appropriate corrections.
However, a similarity index of 25% or below does not automatically establish that a manuscript is free from plagiarism or other forms of academic misconduct.
Likewise, a similarity index exceeding 25% does not, in itself, constitute evidence of plagiarism.
The Editorial Board assesses the nature, extent, distribution, and context of textual similarities before determining whether further revision, clarification, or investigation is required.
3. Evaluation of Similarity Reports
Similarity reports are evaluated through editorial judgement rather than solely on the basis of automated similarity percentages.
In conducting this evaluation, the Editorial Board considers:
-
The extent and concentration of textual overlap with individual sources.
-
Whether direct quotations are accurately presented and appropriately referenced.
-
Whether paraphrased material sufficiently distinguishes the author's original expression from the wording of the source.
-
Whether similarities arise from bibliographical entries, standard terminology, methodological descriptions, or commonly used academic expressions.
-
Whether any substantial portions of text, arguments, or research findings have been reproduced without appropriate acknowledgement.
The Editorial Board may request clarification or revision when concerns arise, regardless of the overall similarity score.
4. Plagiarism and Academic Misconduct
MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi does not tolerate plagiarism or other forms of academic misconduct.
Plagiarism includes the presentation of another person's words, ideas, arguments, interpretations, or research findings as one's own without appropriate acknowledgement.
The journal also considers inappropriate textual recycling, duplicate publication, and substantial unattributed reuse of previously published material to be potential violations of publication ethics.
Where plagiarism or other serious concerns regarding research integrity are identified, the Editorial Board may reject the manuscript or undertake further investigation in accordance with the journal's publication ethics policies.
5. Authors' Responsibilities
Authors are responsible for ensuring that their submissions meet recognised standards of originality, scholarly integrity, and responsible academic writing.
Authors must:
-
Properly acknowledge all sources of ideas, arguments, quotations, and research findings.
-
Use accurate citations and bibliographical references in accordance with The Chicago Manual of Style, 18th Edition (Notes and Bibliography).
-
Clearly distinguish original analysis and interpretation from material derived from other sources.
-
Avoid plagiarism, duplicate submission, inappropriate text recycling, and misleading attribution.
-
Respond appropriately to editorial requests concerning identified textual similarities.
6. Editorial Decision and Transparency
Similarity screening forms part of the journal's preliminary quality assurance and publication ethics procedures.
The results of similarity screening are considered alongside the manuscript's scholarly originality, academic contribution, methodological rigour, and compliance with editorial standards.
No manuscript is automatically accepted or rejected solely on the basis of its similarity percentage.
The Editorial Board retains responsibility for determining whether a manuscript should proceed to peer review, be returned for revision, undergo further investigation, or be rejected on grounds of academic misconduct.
Through this policy, MEDIA: Jurnal Filsafat dan Teologi seeks to maintain a fair, transparent, and academically rigorous editorial process while promoting responsible scholarship in philosophy, theology, and related disciplines.





